First, what is an
Institute?
Well, it's an organisation
founded to promote a cause and/or for carrying on a particular
type of work in a literary, scientific, or educational character.
In some institutions examinations of an individuals
appropriate relevant learning act as a barrier to entry.
These must be passed before full membership and the right
to use the designated letters is allowed. The accounting
bodies operate such a system.
And what is a Charter?
That's a written grant of
rights given by the sovereign to form the creation of an
organisation, for example, a town borough, university or
institute. It defines the written constitution of the organisations
functions and its methods of governance.
Six accounting institutes have Royal Charters.
Chartered Institute
of Management Accountants (CIMA)
| When founded |
1919, as the Institute of
Cost & Works Accountants. It changed its name
in 1986 to reflect the wider scope of modern management
accounting now being provided by its members. |
| Purpose |
To form a body for accountants
who gained experience of cost control during WW1
in munitions factories. |
| Designatory Letters |
ACMA – Associate Chartered
Management Accountant ; FCMA – Fellow C.M.A.
|
| Good for * |
Applied management accounting
techniques
Operational measurement
Change management
Relationship and project
management
Marketing management
Human resources management
|
| Entry Qualifications ** |
Examinations
Practical experience (min.
3 years) in business organisations leading to an
approved career profile evidencing the application
of management accounting skills learned.
Test of professional competence
in management accounting. |
Escape link, go to "The CIMA Difference Summarised for a
simpler comparison"
Institute of Chartered
Accountants in England & Wales (ICAEW)
| When founded |
1880 as ICAEW but formed
from regional institutes and societies the earliest
starting in 1870. |
| Purpose |
The first recorded accounting
firm was founded in 1781 in Bristol undertaking
audit work of merchants books. The 1831 Bankruptcy
Act recognises accountants for the first time. Early
work was mostly derived from insolvency and in 1862
a Companies Act recognised the Official Receiver.
The accountants recognised the benefit of forming
local societies or institutes to band together and
promote their profession. Between 1870 and 1880
these local groups combined into several large institutes
which became one under a Royal Charter from Queen
Victoria. |
| Designatory Letters |
ACA Associate of the Institute
of Chartered Accountants in England & Wales;
FCA Fellow CA. |
| Good for * |
Taxation of corporate and
non-corporate entities
External audit and stakeholder
assurance
Stock exchange regulation
and reporting
Insolvency
Financial accounting and
reporting for statutory audits
Forensic accounting
Corporate Finance
|
| Entry Qualifications ** |
Examinations.
Training contract in a practice
lasting 3 to 5 years.
Completion of Initial Professional
Development requirements.
Completion of Structured
Training in Ethics module.
|
Institute of Chartered
Accountants in Scotland (ICAS)
| When founded |
1951 as ICAS but formed
from regional institutes and societies the earliest
starting in 1853, the first gaining its charter
in 1854. |
| Purpose |
Similar to ICAEW. |
| Designatory Letters |
CA – Chartered Accountant
|
| Good for * |
Taxation of corporate and
non-corporate entities
External audit and stakeholder
assurance
Stock exchange regulation
and reporting
Insolvency
Financial accounting and
reporting for statutory audits
Forensic accounting
Corporate Finance
|
| Entry Qualifications ** |
Examinations
Training contract in a practice
lasting 3 years.
Completion of experience
Achievement Log
|
Association of Chartered
Certified Accountants (ACCA)
| When founded |
1984 as the Chartered Association
of Certified Accountants but formed from other associations,
the earliest starting in 1904. It gained its charter
in 1974. |
| Purpose |
To provide more open access
to the accountancy profession than the existing
accountancy organisations of the time. |
| Designatory Letters |
ACCA - Associate Chartered
Certified Accountants ;
FCCA – Fellow C.C.A.
|
| Good for * |
Taxation of corporate and
non-corporate entities
External audit and stakeholder
assurance
Stock exchange regulation
and reporting
Insolvency
Financial accounting and
reporting for statutory audits
|
| Entry Qualifications ** |
Examinations
Three years practical experience
achieving 13 out of 20 exam linked performance objectives.
|
Chartered Institute of Public
Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA)
| When founded |
1973 as CIPFA but originates
from the Corporate Treasurers and Accountants Institute
formed in 1885. It gained its charter in 1973. |
| Purpose |
|
| Designatory Letters |
CPFA – Chartered Public
Financial Accountant |
| Good for * |
Accounting issues specific
to the public sector
External audit
Taxation
Audit and stakeholder assurance
Public finance and policies
|
| Entry Qualifications ** |
Examinations
|
The sixth charter holder
is the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Ireland (ICAI)
whose profile is similar to the ICAEW and ICAS. These six bodies are represented
by the Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies
(CCAB) whose core objective is to promote and protect
the qualified chartered accountant brand.
Other Accounting Organisations
in the U.K.
Association of International
Accountants
Association of Accounting
Technicians (AAT)
Association of Authorised
Public Accountants
Certified Accounting Technicians,
part of ACCA
Institute of Financial Accountants
International Association
of Bookkeepers
Other Professional
Bodies In Business Finance
The Chartered Institute
of Taxation
Institute of Credit Management
Chartered Financial Analysts
Institute (U.S.)
Other Organisations
You Might Have Heard Of
Financial Accounting Standards
Board (FASB)
The Consultative Committee
of Accountancy Bodies ( CCAB)

"The CIMA Difference Summarised for a
simpler comparison"
Additions
and Corrections
If any of the
above is incorrect or unclear, please send an email to let us know and
we'll rectify the situation. Contributions expanding on the content are
welcome, particularly from the other professional bodies. Contributors
will be credited.
Sources
Websites of
ICAEW, ICAS, CIMA, ACCA and CIPFA; The CIMA difference – document
produced by the University of Bath for CIMA in 2007 to compare the
institutes examination syllabuses; Wikepedia
Disclaimer
This information
is put together to aid non financial business managers understand the
principle differences in the services offered by accountants of the
charter holding bodies. It is taken from information freely available
to the public and is believed to be a true summary of that information.
However, no responsibility can be accepted for the outcomes of actions
implemented using this information and users should complete further
research before proceeding. Furthermore, no responsibility can be
accepted if the interpretations above are subsequently shown to be
untrue and/or cause harm to individuals or organisations.
Maybe John Moon
could come up with some good ideas on how to re-present this page?